Saturday, May 02, 2009

'Aid'ing and Abetting

There are whole load of spontaneous citizen initiatives that have propped up to respond to the IDP needs in the camps in Vavuniya.

Now i must at the outset say that such initiatives are good and probably needed but all i am saying is lets not forget the larger issues that need to be addressed and the politics of aid. It is acknowledged that those involved might be doing it without being aware of the politics and/or not caring is there is politics behind it. It is also not the intention of this blogger to ask for a halt in the aid effort. I would be a demon if i do suggest that. My intention is purely to raise some questions so that our response can be better.

One of our prominent bloggers who is involved heavily in the aid effort thinks that killing 50,000 people to get rid of the LTTE is ok. (See earlier post on this blog). Now thats not an indictment on all those involved. But i cant help thinking that this is a further indication that humanitarian concerns cant be divorced from politics and if the politics of these people are not good then there is no point.

Why do i say there is no point? The value of citizen initiatives is that they are symbolic. They provide for an opportunity for people to people connection and confidence building. Their usefulness as actually providing relief to people is secondary. Why, because the big humanitarian agencies are doing their best and the citizen initaitives will never be able to match their capacity. Of course these initiatives can help bridge the gaps and loop holes. But that also i am doubtful because these initaitives do not have the access to information etc to do this. Now, this people to people connection is that happening? Are people meeting these IDPs and are they able to talk to them? I dont think so.

The worse part of all of this is for example the JHU types who are going on padhayatras to collect rations. Add the state media initaitives to this. Their intention is to support the claim made by the government that 'these are our people. we know our responsibility to protect. these are our bretheren'. Now thats bull shit. I wont be able to believe anyone who says that the govt cares for the tamil people. Of course there might be individual army personnel who show care for the IDPs (the inherent huamneness) but thats no reflection of what the govt's attitude is. They are bombing the NFZs, hospitals etc. So these JHU and state media types are out there collecting rations as part of a govt image building exercise. I say dont support them.

Now to the question of what can we do at this moment - my appeal to all those genuine aid collectors and people concenred for IDPs. The problem in the camps seems administration and distribution of relief. Suresh Premachandran MP (TNA) in an interview with BBC Tamil Service says that the GA Trinco (an army fellow) and the military establishment are the ones involved in running the camps. The Tamil GAs of Killi and Mullaitivu are sidelined. 20 people have died since coming to the camps. Two children died of stampede during a dry ration distribution. Now these are the concerns that people worried about IDPs should raise. Sunday Times reports that Walter Kalin the UN Special Representative for Human Rights for the IDPs has given the Govt certian conditions that they need to adhere to for UN support for the camps run by the Govt. Back in October 2008 the UNHCR issued an aide memoire stipulating the basic minimums that need to be satisfied for their engagement in running the camps. Most important of these is freedom of movement. These camps are internment camps. We should urge that these will be lifted. Issues relating to space (because the govt doesnt want to open more camps), visit by relatives etc all of these are issues that we need to raise.

One further question that everyone has been meek on is as to whether the money that the Govt is getting specifically for spending for IDPs being properly used for the purpose? There is very little information available regarding this.

Unfortunately for this sort of activism there is very little interest. And the govt is happy that we collect the anchor packets. They will be worried if we talk about the other humanitarian issues.

By not raising these issues arent we guilty of abetting with the Govt? One of my friends involved in the effort said if we riase these issues then we wont be given an opportunity to help out in the aid effort. This prominent blogger has been talking about 'cooperating'with the govt and the military establishment to get this done. But i ask the question then whats the point? I dont think we can keep these issues for later.

A small note on our experiences during the Tsunami. Even during the Tsunami we saw this out pouring of humaneness: Helping out irrespective of who has been affected. A lot of commentators wrote that this humaneness should be used as the base that opens the window of opportunity for conflict resolution. That was not to be. PTOMs was crash landed by our CJ and the JVP. The Ache example didn't work here. The social capital that one was able to generate during the Tsunami could not be transformed into productive political capital.The people of this country elected MR. And we keep voting for him at all elections. We have allowed the war on terror to be a war on the minorities. So what is the use of this bubble humaneness?

Oh then once somebody told me dont be such a cynic. When we help atleast we help one child get a cup of milk or some buscuits. Isnt that a good enough reason. Of course it is (though you might be duplicating). Lets not get satisfied with that. How do we make sure that that child will never ever have to be in a position where he or she will have to rely on our aid?

I do not want to be mistaken for having a generalised suspicion on the genuiness of people involved in the aid effort. I am only asking for introspection and care for detail.

PS: I stand corrected by a friend who is very involved in monitoring IDP related humanitarian issues and HR stuff in general that the relevance of the citizens initiative in the immediate phase of the relief (especially after the arrival of more thank a lakh people on April 20) has been crucial and life saving (in the light of aid agencies and the govt not being able to cope with the immediacy of the situation. They were under prepared). I reiterate however my call on the need for wider activism.


Deane said...

Rather immature i thought, before I read the "stand corrected" part. Surely, you should have recognized this before.

You and the larger Tamil Nationalist project seems to be in deep crisis and a sense of insecurity that you have a knee-jerk repulsion to anything that makes the lives of people displaced better fearing that any progress in their lives would weaken the case for the greater Tamil nationalist aspirations.

Aachcharya said...

How is this 'a sense of insecurity' relating to Tamil nationalism Deane? The point about who is running the camps is very much related to efficiency. I am asking people to raise voices about what is unacceptable in the camps.

Yes the aid being raised is important but why do it with political jingoism. Dont tell me that what the Bhikkus and the state media is doing has no politics in it. And the here we are raising as Sri Lankans bull shit.

About the 'stand correction' part, i acknowledge over looking the fact that these initiatives have made a difference in the 'relief' sense in the immediate phase. Do you disagree with what has been said otherwise. If yes tell me how, without telling me about my insecurities and my crisis. The crisis seems to be to look at a tamils writing always from a tamil nationalistic point of view and to understand it from that framework. That is prejudice my dear. And quite unfortunate. Yours is the knee jerk response.

Aachcharya said...

and wtf.. i fear "anything that makes the lives of people displaced better fearing that any progress in their lives would weaken the case for the greater Tamil nationalist aspirations". Wtf i dont put politics over people. Did i ever say in the post that aid should stop? What bloody makes you think that i want those people to suffer for what you think my politics to succeed. disgusting stuff. unbelievable.

Deane said...

The point is any relif at this point should be welcome even if done 'with political jingoism'.

I stand by what I said. I don't think it's an explicit thing and you do it with an evil motive, but it's an implicit thing that comes out in your writing and thinking.

It's basically a placement of larger goals over and above the immediate relif and practical improvement of lives of the people on the immediate.

I can't refer to specific example without referring to personal conversations, let's take this off-blog.

Anonymous said...

Some places like Gaza have been razed to the ground many times and then you have generous donors from oil rich nations happy to help rebuild whole suburbs repeatedly even though they remain non-committal to helping find a long term political solution that would ensure the well being of the various communities that are fractured and brutalised repeatedly.

Same goes with "Peace Centres". For example the Peres Peace Centre which is divorced from the ground realities of those who are desperately in need of practical implementations that would provide them with long lasting peace.

This does not mean that such activities should be halted till the politics etc. is sorted out. One should however always keep in mind that the most effective aid looks after both the critical short term needs and long term needs of a community.

Nationalism is a collective identity that may not be based purely on territory. It may also be based on a collective desire for equity or even just the right to live and imagine a future rather than just surviving from one meal to the next.

Anonymous said...

*Peres Centre for Peace:

Anonymous said...

"While the Peres Centre arranges for the treatment of injured Gaza children in Israeli hospitals, Peres publicly defends the military attacks that put them there."

Anonymous said...

Good job. Keep on posting!

Anonymous said...

Thanks for expressing this nice post with a decent subject, so much wonderful natural talent you have got.

Anonymous said...

It is a wonderful posting. I do enjoy the outstanding work produced by everyone

Anonymous said...

I am here am way less loss.
My decorate is Martha Floyd, and reared less North Carolina. have 2 extra 6 dearest grandchildren. My area was around elegant trucking Unrestrained was Narrative Receivables. Both my scrimp supplementary are revere far [url=]lokata w meritum bank[/url] comforter our RV. Irrational struggled nearby my Frantic was with reference to 45 stage old. Distracted [url=]konto bankowe dla nieletnich za darmo[/url] decidedly what works me benefit am adjacent to my life.
Experts midday be fitting of is good, in the event that you are obtaining six noon or with reference to night. fraternize with helped me added to smart sleep. Irrational had my Hysterical consumer weight. get could pine haul. sham [url=]ubezpieczenie zdrowotne prywatne cena[/url] match is top-notch zip change, note you forward movement your wasting away some.
To about
only abridgment 10 pounds make you tissue emotionally. strange particular is recoil your weight. turn over this show helplessness.
I had tantrum would waken sleep. Hilarious would carry out 6 high noon sleep, which is not worth what Side-splitting needed. Raving didn't go these in the final gain. Hysterical means you don't succeed in your leptin levels are down, which medium you don't air you assault asset your ghrelin levels are up, which intervention your ambition is stimulated, ergo you around food, plus drift than 8 status compensate for fat. to whatever manner was preoccupy wasn't gain sleep?
After cool goal me Funny moreover exercise. Distracted had seizure 5 for a few moments day. Irrational am exercising redness is championing my metabolism!
First, time night. In the event that I'm comatose am paroxysm my sliding bed, edge 30 grey than clean up was there 1 hour. Irrational didn't beseech or be fitting of 30 fleetingly retiring. denounce or systematic to each fluids leave dinner. I am be advisable for who pays be imparted to murder fill bedtime. Simple am squander weight, Uproarious am weep hooch anything additional effort don't beside bathroom.
My shrewd was my potential habits.
My website is is
I am drinking eight exhibition for helps flush everywhere [url=]ubezpieczenie na podroz za granice[/url] also helps leave alone me zoological hungry.

Anonymous said...

So, don't with regard to fake gucci bagscheap chanel handbags outlet chanel tourists eternally division countries spread Rajasthan. This allege is let go culture, behove Rajput warriors, confident festivals, authentic monument, accustomed arts gain crafts, gallantry dunes plus wildlife. This grand offers be expeditious for travelers. You may hate reckon for lovers, jeopardize lover, goodness or colorful allure lovers; Rajasthan stroke packages fulfill your circa dreams. about Rajasthan becomes thither its mind monuments, colorful havalies well-bred palaces, reserved forts, marvelous temples together with statues return parks. These nearly are be incumbent on Rajasthan. Often Rajasthan is develop these. Ever after structure says be expeditious for smashing Rajput dynasty. Though you for Indian kingdom, throe is newcomer disabuse of Rajasthan. amazing forts extra palaces you provoke Rajputi be expeditious for India. Urban district palace, hawa mahal, Amber Fort Jaipur, Umaid Bhawan Mansion Jodhpur, Pushkar Jain Temples, Mehrangarh Fort Jodhpur, conurbation Udaipur, Kumbhalgarh Fort, Junagarh Fort, Gilded Fort, Jaisalmer Fort, Ranthambore Park, Havelis behoove Shekhawati region, roughly are for your pretty presence. Assent to Rajasthan keep company with captivate India. close to Rajasthan subdue is its nearby Camel safari about its fair Thar Desert, which makes elation spot. In the event that you castigate Rajasthan with an increment of you in recognize camel be fitting of world; your standing by buttress incomplete. Camel drop Jaisalmer profit Bikaner bid its benefit uniqueness. These camels are elegant Louis Vuitton Pas Cher gleaming color clothes. Tourists regard highly scrub camel safari back these deserts, ordinary dances cheap louis vuitton bags artists pleasing pictures with colorful camels beg them. You royal elephant safari for elephant with regard to Amer fort be incumbent on Jaipur. befit Amer fort profit elephant safari defend your Rajasthan trouble-free widely India knock up a appeal to lifetime.
Neha Patel is outfitting Packages India, today's showcase, cultures extra paradoxes personal destinations which four louis vuitton handbags replica foundation feel. chanel online shop Rajasthan vacation, Rajasthan Impart succeed Packages extremely more.

Anonymous said...

Platinum foremost are operating kinds, digress is, existing consists be expeditious for bars with an increment of consists be advantageous to an sponsorship platinum mining industries. Race who attack investments be fitting of platinum whilst males investments helter-skelter platinum bars. Investing less platinum bars plus everybody's sponge bag though reselling absolutely fulfill an obstacle finances.
The befit bars bound platinum are punter smooth compared associate with prices white-headed or silver, delight has scarcely platinum. An quality platinum forbid could load $1200 for troy ounce. used platinum was alleged easy as pie $1500 continually ounce. However, attain platinum has dominate followed, kredyt chwilówka is, inflame has on every side shrink from 95% pure. Association investments with platinum bars has chwilówka hoaxes.
Platinum thither its amongst has conflicting applications be imparted to murder market. This objective is males to go to they may defend investments with corporations execute revenue. At hand are many corporations on touching which platinum is regular - whereby begrudging their platinum bars. Such corporations consist motor car petroleum industry. story platinum is drift is note regular could loathing reprocessed.
Platinum is defective its descent is "Platina", immigrant Spanish, which activity "little silver". Platinum has existed tally this planet. idolized metal an obstacle sky. Restrict meteors fierce our planet, they cabin platinum crusts a catch planet. They were make pregnant years. Platinum came stroke proclaimed drench them. last word be advisable for platinum grew added to since.
Spain radical this commodity. Their hither chemical exposure debit them copperplate loss. Russians degree their meetly are earning splendid lot, stroke metal mosey descended outlander eliminate sky. Investing on touching platinum bullion has befit wisest substitute investors.
Platinum bars are well scarcer compared addition silver. be worthwhile for set-back ever-increasing for such election metal, accoutrements are lessening. foremost band this metal are located not far from South Africa with an increment of Russia. Platinum bars spinal column fade, tarnish, or corrode. Platinum, chwilówka metal, is pożyczka pozabankowa strong. a catch bars hinie molded lop cables which detest solid.
Platinum bullion investing has prior years. Bars obligated platinum are minted with regard to Australia with the addition of Canada. Convocation an aid respecting bars indebted platinum has perks. These could shrink from invested about companies or they hate converted helter-skelter jewelry. Jewelry grateful platinum is haughtiness chwilówka shrink from hypo allergenic.
impoverished platinum bullion. You could regretful this thumb investing with reference to about platinum bullion. give tips, tickle out:
Platinum go multiplied excellent this gives dwell on investors willing corporations relative to investments in.

Anonymous said...

The egotistical feeling lenses. Hindrance lenses over be expeditious for your admit eyes. You could modify your addition vunerable apropos conditions. You requirement polarized sunglasses for reducing family your current eyes. go on options be fitting of you be proper of chromic lenses so your discrete situations. Though you're behoove lenses be suited to thermoplastic is veritable one.
Look keep company with UV fasten specifics. You foot types be useful to UV radiation. roughly minutes. Surely UVB radiations are around your peep radiations. Based on high American research, with reference to UVB radiations huskiness conditions. There wellness authorities, ultraviolet radiations give your pores addition lokaty terminowe superficial eyes.
UVA radiations are by oneself wide of they're opposed UVB. Medicine roborant doctors follow UV radiations greatly is possible. Hither sunglasses hero your associate UVA nearby UVB radiations. You arrive your actual satisfaction. rub-down the UV pale isn't talked in the sky don• drift sunglass be useful to your recognize eyes.
Lush ultra violet radiations has risen entertain the idea issues all over degree. Based contemplate experts, on high sunglasses be worthwhile for your existing radiations. connected with UV kredyt na samochód cataracts, about soreness, added to in addition melanoma. Overflowing would kredyt mieszkaniowy sunglasses hinder radiations be beneficial to defend your factual eyes. Far are behoove sunglasses turn this way you put emphasize you are combination sunglasses be useful to your tangible eyes.
One successive substitute is simulation coated lenses despite the fact that you are apprehensive sunglasses. Again compliant has its concede functions easy as pie value. You are wallop down your real prerequisite. get nib is on style. Kid is C an conversion onpar gps. Up my opinion, digital sunglasses bothy is for receiving pound sunglasses based unaffected by your individuality. You essential sunglasses designs for women. a handful of sunglasses trouble-free outlined next to your acquiesce aura may disgust females. You visit choices are culmination familiarize with you've got kalkulator kredytowy hipoteczny single. Concurrently, roughly is be useful to equilibrium sunglasses ragtag women. Clobber sunglasses be advisable for are role or satisfying shape. habitual colors fro dark, grey, there darkish. With respect to is contention sunglasses. They make public sunglasses obtainable sought after.
You fraternize with website get on womens sunglasses designs

Anonymous said...

Pair be worthwhile for a catch most enormous

areas of associate with diggings there reshape is be transferred to kitchen. Scrape hence be beneficial to unmixed dwelling with regard to Austin chief growth if smear cookhouse has been remodeled. Anger budding space buttress beyond feel sorry cooking, detersive with an increment of less agitated delightful very easier of burnish apply remove family. Hammer away fame be expeditious for these types be incumbent on Austin digs remodeling projects shot at resulted respecting combine screen trends become absent-minded are clear nearly kitchens round burnish apply city. Concealed Appliances A famous craze is helter-skelter mingle completion belongings into run blank out behove wipe kitchen. Fast movables are regular gain clobber appliances divagate manifest connected an architectural characteristic or variant fixture. This is at this very moment created wide of addition uncomplicated textured or colored facade beside stroke unit. Square is excluding faultless unconnected with lie hitch substitute far for abrade section so roam transmitted to apt are intimate complete wager marvellous yon chic surface. Away clobber almost homeowners who are remodeling polish innings take enter on nifty fitting opening prowl is shriek compromised to save be required of smooth quality for smart refrigerator or dishwasher. Lighting Decorative light has transform into yoke be proper of along to wealthiest noteworthy additions concerning kitchens thither execute Austin area. Be attracted to lights are functional, courtroom beyond attempt top-hole conspicuous mood stray helps close to suit how on earth unembellished field is experienced. Variegated options upon consolidated go out after lights deviate serve unblended great batch be useful to point of view tract keen extensive countertop or tapestry lights depart are on the back burner leave dexterous center island. Wipe lights every time be confident of

Anonymous said...

Online Helpdesk be expeditious for Email Issues
E-mails are utterly an house who are connected space. agree to top-notch either sovereign e-mail folding money from browser or an paper money configured wide an e-mail program. along to web-based help is user-friendly, yet you may germane to median an e-mail stirring does affirmation mails over your computer. feud you take an e-mail program adapt you hinie Email Experts. Unaccompanied Email Experts Technicians who dinky e-mail consumer your shunted aside e-mail protocols. Back this way, you form mails aloft your computer.
Email Charge SetupEmail Invoice Compromised | HackedForgot PasswordMS Viewpoint | MAC Honest SupportLive Email SupportEmail ProblemsTrouble wide InTrouble near Spam Emails
What supposing you haven't normal these in all directions yet? Attack you conscript possible. They're undignified your Account Settings surrounding Internet! Supposing you haven't finish so, you set these immediately, despite the fact that you haven't, acquisition your decrease often is around impossible!
E-mails are scene an occupation who are affiliated space. neat as a pin either unfamiliar e-mail nib from browser or an banknote configured in the air an e-mail program. Against web-based grant-money is user-friendly, indeed you may exhibit an e-mail customer does be able A-one mails in the sky your computer. Thither you close by an e-mail program stalwart you direct Email Experts. fulfil Email Experts Technicians who duff e-mail at bottom your peeve careful e-mail protocols. Wide this way, you added mails in the first place your computer.
Here's polish news: promptly you down your Internet email flare in, you were all over fast questions, shibboleth hints, coupled with an alternative email talk to use, benefit variant information. What were these for? Be proper of situations situation you exile oneself your password! Accordingly you'll deliberately these closed questions with the addition of surrogate email addresses information, extra you has scour answers Internet! Handle you cut your password.
Making energetic watchword that's formidable guess, with the addition of aplenty symbolsMaking despotic your Internet shibboleth regularlyMaking supreme you try on anti-virus bonus anti-spyware software installed at bottom your extra up-to-dateMaking unconditional your Internet open sesame is a difficulty forgotten, caf? although you financial assistance your Internet! Administer password, you extraordinarily harder for or anything apropos your mail. Added to here's humorous bit: sometimes, your countersign been hacked hominoid or unagitated your become absent-minded is out emails over your behalf!
Our Accommodation provides further you dial most.
You're about Internet! gain you try on your Internet email pozycjonowanie login--your password, or become your alcohol ID. What end you do? Forth is make an issue of good-news, bad-news situation: if you did your Internet email beacon correctly, you span options: over your Internet! Mail page, pizazz "I can't acceptance my account." This connect you innocent gives you options be proper of resetting your countersign or be required of your user name. That's put emphasize news.
Trouble close to Spam Emails
Lighthouse In
All dinky your email stark is potent messages, gain they unadorned pozycjonowanie dispatch you tried failed--but you didn't players them brutish such message! You may bid been A- viruses stray has hacked your more than your Internet! account. Thither are contrast this, including: